Can You Make Tiramisu Without Coffee?

Table of Contents

We know tiramisu without coffee sounds like sacrilege. But what if you don’t like coffee? What if you despise coffee in puddings? What if coffee makes you roll in your grave? Fret not! We have the solution for you.

In this article, we are going to show you exactly how to make a delicious tiramisu without coffee.

What is tiramisu and where did it come from?

Among Italian foods, tiramisu is probably the most well-known. It is a traditional Italian dessert that is served in restaurants across the world.

There are several origin stories for this famous dessert. People say that it came from Treviso, a city near Venice. Others say that the dish was made by the mistress of a brothel. What is certain, however, is that the recipe was first published by Pellegrino Artusi in 1891.

The dish was also mentioned by Giovanni Comisso, a poet and scholar from Treviso. In his memoirs, he mentioned a dish similar to tiramisu. This recipe was a fusion of egg yolks and sugar and the resulting mixture was poured onto ladyfingers and served. It was also said that the mixture would raise dead people!

Can You Make Tiramisu Without Coffee

Coffee is an essential ingredient in tiramisu

So, tiramisu is a popular dessert originating from Italy, where, incidentally, it’s still the most popular dessert by far. Being a combination of coffee, cocoa, and mascarpone, it is usually served plain or topped with whipped cream and is even available in a boozy version (yum) that’s served in small glass dishes.

But, the one essential ingredient, and the one that gives it a distinctive taste, is coffee.

Coffee that has a rich, dark flavor goes well with creamy mascarpone. It also helps to counterbalance the sweetness of the mascarpone, but getting the right balance between coffee and mascarpone is important.

Beware: if too much mascarpone is added, the dessert will lose its identity!

However, for those of us who want a classic tiramisu without coffee, you can still enjoy a creamy tiramisu, only with an added twist.

What are the substitutes for coffee in Tiramisu?

Traditionally, tiramisu is made with coffee liqueur. However, there are many alternatives. These include Kahlua, coffee extract, and sweetened condensed milk. Each of these has its own distinct flavor.

Alternatively, you could use coffee-flavored liquors, like amaretto, Irish cream, or port. You could also use chocolate syrup. Some people even like fruit tiramisu. You can mix orange and lemon juice into the mixture for a citrusy flavor.

Tiramisu can be served in individual dishes, or you can assemble it in a round plate or pie dish. It can also be served cold. It can be topped with cocoa powder or whipped cream.

How do you make a non-coffee version of tiramisu?

Making a scrumptious and creamy non-coffee version of tiramisu is actually much simpler than you’d think!

All that is needed are ladyfingers, pudding mix, heavy cream, white sugar, and your favorite flavorings.

Before making tiramisu, make sure that your mascarpone is at room temperature. If it’s too warm, the cream will curdle, which is not the best thing to have in your dessert. You can also try substituting sponge cake for the ladyfingers. This is a popular option.

Depending on what type of flavor you’d like to create with your tiramisu, you can substitute different ingredients such as flavored puddings or gelatins for the plain pudding mix.

Also, adding elements like cocoa powder or cocoa bars will give the tiramisu an enjoyable chocolatey twist without the strong essence of coffee.

Start by substituting semi-sweet baking chocolate for the espresso or a few teaspoons of cocoa powder along with some warm water or your favorite espresso substitute can work excellently as an alternative.

The other option is to use a fruit puree for a caffeine-free dessert. You can also substitute the heavy cream with egg whites.

Once all ingredients have been chosen and prepped for assembly, layer the pudding and flavoring mixtures with the ladyfingers within a dish or pan of your choosing.

Next, place in the refrigerator for 2-3 hours before serving to ensure that everything has been properly set together.

Finally, top with freshly grated chocolate and refrigerate until ready to serve. By following these tips you’ll be able to enjoy an unforgettable tiramisu any time you’d like!

It’s that simple.


Tiramisu is a delicious Italian dessert that can be made with or without coffee. If you don’t like coffee, or you want to try something different, you can make a non-coffee tiramisu. It’s just as tasty and will give you a chance to experiment with other flavors. Have you tried non-coffee tiramisu? If so, what did you think Leave a comment

Other Posts

About the author

Coffee addict and self confessed obsessive with all things Java, Dave loves to write about coffee nearly as much as he enjoys drinking it. Can always be found no more than 2 feet away from a fresh brew!

Share this review

Other Interesting Reads

Yearn to explore the rich tapestry of Arabian coffee traditions in Jordan? Dive in to experience the deep cultural significance of Al-Qahwa.
Posted byBen West
Tap into the surprising health benefits of Papaya Coffee, an exotic blend packed with antioxidants, vitamins, and vital immune support.
Posted byBen West
Perfect your coffee ordering skills by understanding the subtle differences between coffee types, aligning your choice with your mood and weather.
Posted byBen West
Immerse yourself in the enchanting, yet contrasting coffee cultures of Greece and Turkey, and discover how they both foster social connectivity.
Posted byBen West
“Coffee is a language in itself.” – Jackie Chan Welcome to the captivating world of Scandinavian coffee culture, where every cup tells a story. With its rich history, unique traditions, and inviting customs, coffee holds a special place in the hearts of those in the Nordic region. From the bustling...
Posted byDave Reed
Did you know that despite the coffee market’s revenue amounting to $88 billion in 2023, farmers receive only 7 to 10% of the marked retail prices? It’s a shocking statistic that highlights the need for ethical considerations in coffee sourcing. With 62% of Americans drinking coffee daily and consuming an...
Posted byDave Reed